![]() |
| Credit: Google |
Another chosen article was "Walking for Survival" by Robert Wilbur where he states that since the 1950's cardiologists and fitness experts have linked physical activity to prevention and recovery to heart attacks. "The American Heart Association added inactivity to the list of risk factors for heart disease." Wilbur points out that there is not much data to prove that physical activity could be linked to heart attacks. He also noted that in other articles mentioned strenuous activities such as weightlifting can trigger a heart attack. He mentions Victor Froelicher, M.D, a founder of the American Association of Cardiopulmonary Rehabilitation formed a theory that aerobic exercises make the body more relaxed and decrease the work of the heart, preventing a heart attack. Wilbur mentions more studies need to be done.
After reviewing both articles I find that there are many differences when the authors are writing about exercise. I see two different point of views; in the first article the author based his views on a study and quotes from doctors. He stated that exercise has a lot to do with our health later in life, as well as preventing disease and how it can be very beneficial for us. In the second article the author is trying to prove that there is not much evidence out there that proves inactivity is leading to heart disease. He stated that more studies and research need to be done. After reading the articles I want to try to find other articles with proven studies and research on how exercise can be beneficial on ones body. Everybody has there own point of views on the kind of activity they do or not do at all.
Works Cited
American
Heart Association. “Health Tips to Get Active, Exercise.” Online Video Clip. YouTube. YouTube, 27 Mar. 2013. Web. 30 June 2016.
"Exercise
Is Still The Best Medicine." Harvard
Heart Letter 25.3 (2014): 1-7.
Academic Search Premier. Web. 1 July 2016.
Wilbur,
Robert. "Walking For SURVIVAL."
American Fitness 19.5 (2001): 53.
Academic Search Premier. Web. 30 June 2016.

I found the juxtaposition of confidence in data between your sources especially interesting. I am interested to see if you come across more similar opinions to those of your second source, or if that second source is an anomaly in the bigger picture.
ReplyDeleteIn regard to the second source it may be interesting to expand in the summary what Wilbur attributes as other main/more important reasons than exercise. Perhaps diet? Genetics? It might not have mentioned in the article, I just became curious after seeing their viewpoint if they offered any better alternatives.
I agree with your idea to continue to research clinically in search of proven studies to help you weigh the viewpoint of the two different authors. I am interested to see what the statistics are between both sides of the this argument.
I find your topic to be very interesting. I feel that there is a lot of debate about exercise, especially recently, and what exactly the benefits are. I guess one thing that you could add would be-- where were these articles in agreement, specifically? Is there something that they both fully stand behind?
ReplyDeleteI definitely think it's a great idea to look more into research studies being done, to back up some of the information you're finding. It would be a great asset. Not only would you have qualified people saying one thing or the other, but you would have results to make your point stand out. Great job!
I find your topic to be very interesting. I feel that there is a lot of debate about exercise, especially recently, and what exactly the benefits are. I guess one thing that you could add would be-- where were these articles in agreement, specifically? Is there something that they both fully stand behind?
ReplyDeleteI definitely think it's a great idea to look more into research studies being done, to back up some of the information you're finding. It would be a great asset. Not only would you have qualified people saying one thing or the other, but you would have results to make your point stand out. Great job!